Michael hands out ice cream sandwiches instead of the surprise
Michael returns with ice cream sandwiches, tossing them around the office, and insists this is not the big surprise.

Every The Office moment featuring Angela Martin, in story order. Played by Angela Kinsey.
48 moments · 1h 22m · by Favseen
Moments 1–30 of 48
Michael returns with ice cream sandwiches, tossing them around the office, and insists this is not the big surprise.
Abandoning confidentiality, Dwight reads out submitted conditions for a show of hands, setting off an uncomfortable office debate.
Michael pins the bad plan on Dwight, runs out the clock, is pushed to reveal his surprise, then imagines going toe to toe with Robin Williams.
Angela, Phyllis and Pam deadlock over streamers, Michael shows off his planners, then pushes an ice cream cake on a dairy-allergic guest.
Losing the room, Michael flaunts his per-mile pledge and imagines being a philanthropist whose anonymous gift everyone knows is his.
Michael asks Pam to cheer in pigtails, warns his team about playing badly with an unfortunate word, and sidelines Angela as an alternate.
Ryan the temp wins Hottest in the Office and has no idea what to do with it; Angela refuses her award and Kelly questions her bowling trophy.
Someone owns up to the bathroom writing; then Pam is helped out to Angela's car and turns a question into a simple thanks.
An echoing opening ceremony lights a bathroom candle, sets yogurt-lid medals on the honor system, and Angela insists she plays games, just not at work.
Michael rents Dwight the spare room as a reward, Dwight's questions pile up until Michael ends it, and Angela reveals her own game: Pam Pong.
Angela picks the Bible, Dwight smuggles survival gear inside a book, Michael gives Ryan rule four, and Meredith's movies spark a rules fight.
Roy can't recall Angela's name, Jim picks Kevin, and Dwight dashes back into the building to fetch Michael's cell phone.
Michael approves new party decorations, then asks accounting to find a full salary in the numbers, and pitches Kelly a better costume idea.
Angela's review ends in seconds when Jan calls; Michael tries for closure about the Chili's parking lot and lies about the cameras.
Dwight warns Angela to delete her sensitive e-mails, Jim and Pam put it together with disgust, and Jim probes Dwight with a 'friend' question.
Reading Meredith's e-vite, Michael finds every name but his, then tries to be 'approachabler' at lunch with a Cup of Noodles and party tales.
Michael's hang-out offer is turned down, so he claims improv class, then quizzes everyone on their evenings; Dwight invents soccer practice.
Angela sulks, paper talk is banned, and Pam's question to Phyllis about secret romances turns back on her and Jim; she drops her side project.
Michael storms the party planning committee, doubles every order, flashes his 3,000-dollar bonus for firing Devon, and is reminded liquor is banned.
Michael keeps the Santa hat, staff admit who they drew, Michael brags about overspending on Ryan, and the countdown lighting fizzles.
Jim's teapot gets swiped, Angela's creepy baby poster circulates, the iPod changes hands, and Michael pulls off reverse psychology.
Michael assigns Gilligan's Island roles at the dock, then fights Captain Jack over who is captain and who gives the safety speech.
Phyllis and Angela pick between Jim and Roy, Dwight recounts his surveillance past, and Jim tries to downplay it all.
Michael and Dwight sweep Accounting's desks clean, then Michael's carpet theories climb from love and hate to terrorism.
Shushing complaints and girlfriend gripes turn into talk of unequal pay and a union, which Michael ends up cheering on.
Michael guides the camera past Times Square chain restaurants and Rockefeller Center, mistakes a stranger for Tina Fey, and hypes his presentation.
Dwight plans a Mordor hike, then gets advice to pound his fists like history's great orators, from a speech that turns out to be Mussolini's.
Michael badly misjudges Melissa's age and explains he prefers being the fun uncle; Kelly gushes about babies while Ryan quietly panics.
Michael soaks up birthday wishes and shows off a one-of-a-kind suit, Dwight angles to run the party, and the planners get a surprise list.
Oscar vents to Toby about Angela's poster; Michael mocks Toby's listening approach, calls a mediation and explains his five styles of conflict.